Ever wonder what your friendly editor is really thinking when she emails or calls to talk about your manuscript? Here’s a handy-dandy guide to help you understand the deeper meaning behind her words.*
***
When your editor says: “I really like the basic plot. Nicely done!”
Your editor is thinking: “Okay, there are 90,000 words here, so that’s a start. And the story has characters and they do stuff. That’s a good thing, too. But whoa baby there’s a ton of work to do. I’m going to have some long nights with this puppy.”
***
When your editor says: “I’m not sure the subplot about the missing orangutan is working as written.”
Your editor is thinking: “The subplot about the missing orangutan is unsalvageable.”
***
When your editor says: “I think I see what you’re trying to do with this…”
Your editor is thinking: “I have no freakin’ idea what you’re trying to do with this but surely in the next draft it will make some measure of sense… surely then…?”
***
When your editor says: “This paragraph on page 94 is amazing!”
Your editor is thinking: “I wish there were more paragraphs like the one on page 94!”
***
When your editor says: “The middle section drags somewhat…”
Your editor is thinking: “The middle section needs a complete re-write…”
***
When your editor says: “The word count is a little high.”
Your editor is thinking: “We’ll have to cut 50,000 words.”
***
When your editor says: “Don’t be too put off by all my editorial notes.”
Your editor is thinking: “Please don’t hate me, please don’t hate me, please don’t hate me…”
***
When your editor says: “If you cut phrases like this one you’ll have a much stronger narrative.”
Your editor is thinking: “I just know you labored over these phrases. But the thing is – they’re overwrought, distracting and pretentious. If only you would read them aloud you’d see just how unwieldy they are. I hope you don’t fight to keep these. Choose a different battle. Okay?”
***
When your editor says: “The dialogue is clunky.”
Your editor is thinking: “The dialogue sounds like it’s coming from soulless cardboard robots.”
***
When your editor says: “Thanks for all the hard work you’ve put into this.”
Your editor is thinking: “Thanks for all the hard work you’ve put into this. Really, I mean it. Writing and re-writing is no picnic and I’ve been throwing you curve balls and stirring the pot and invoking dozens of other clichés and yet you’re still standing. I will now drink a glass of wine in your honor. You should have one too. No, a glass of wine, not an entire bottle. You can put the bottle down now… really, put the bottle… okay, fine. Yes, you are a damn good writer. Better than Faulkner. And Fizzy Gerald, better than him, too. What’s that? Yes, I love you too. Go to bed now.”
*This entire post is a mild attempt at humor. Seriously, I mean it. In truth, all editors are painfully transparent and almost never hide what they’re really thinking.
The Contest. Just click here and enter. Okay? Because if you don’t, the terrorists win.
Comments
4 responses to “What Your Editor Is Thinking”
I just stumbled upon your blog, (Really. From Stumbleupon,) and I love it. Too bad I’m not a novelist or I would have found my new home. I will be back because I love your style, and you probably have a few tips in here that I could use. I’m just a blogger but that doesn’t mean that there isn’t room for improvement, right?
I’m glad you stumbled in this general direction. I’m even gladder that you like what you’ve read so far.
Please make yourself at home here, novel aspirations or not. All are welcome. Especially bloggers. Some of my very best friends are bloggers.
Just remembered to add you to my blog at wordpress. Now much easier for me to check in and catch up with the great info. you provide. Thanks. This last post tickled my funny bone!
: )
Well, you may SAY you’re kidding, but I know for a fact you’re telling the truth. Well said. You’re spot on!